Percentages people get wrong, and how to work them out

A percentage is a one-line formula, yet the answer often comes out wrong because the number it is taken from is the wrong one. Here are five calculations that trip people up, with figures you can check yourself.

Updated

One rule: divide by the starting value

A percentage is always a share of some base. A price that rises from 80 to 100 goes up by 20 ÷ 80 = 25%. A price that falls from 100 to 80 goes down by 20 ÷ 100 = 20%. The difference is the same 20, but the base is not. Nearly every mistake below comes from using the wrong base.

Stacked discounts: 40% plus 25% is not 65%

The second discount is taken off the price left after the first, not off the original price.

StepWorkingPrice
Marked price120.00
40% off40% × 120 = 4872.00
Extra 25% off25% × 72 = 1854.00

You save 66, which is 55% of the marked price, not 65%. In one step: 1 − (1 − 0.40) × (1 − 0.25) = 0.55. The order of the discounts does not change the result, and 50% off plus another 50% off is 75% off, not free.

Percent and percentage points

When a mortgage rate goes from 6% to 7.5%, it has risen by 1.5 percentage points. Compared with the old rate, that is a 25% increase: 1.5 ÷ 6 = 0.25. A savings rate that moves from 4.25% to 4.75% rises by 0.5 points, or 11.76%. "Rates rose 25%" and "rates rose 1.5%" can describe the same change, so check which one is meant.

Equal percentage rises and falls do not cancel out either. A price of 100 that rises 50% becomes 150; a 50% fall then takes it to 75. Going back from 80 to 100 needs a 25% rise, although the fall from 100 to 80 was only 20%.

Successive rises are not added up

A rent of 24,000 a year that rises 10% every year becomes 26,400, then 29,040, then 31,944. After three 10% rises it is 33.1% higher, not 30%, because each rise is taken from the already higher rent: 1.1 × 1.1 × 1.1 = 1.331. Two 5% pay rises in a row add up to 10.25%. When you compare multi-year contracts, multiply the factors instead of adding the percentages.

Adding and removing VAT or sales tax

To add tax, multiply by 1 plus the rate. To remove it, divide by the same number. With the UK standard VAT rate of 20%:

  • Adding VAT to a price of 250: 250 × 1.20 = 300, of which 50 is VAT.
  • Removing VAT from 300: 300 ÷ 1.20 = 250.
  • The common mistake: 300 minus 20% is 240, which is 10 too low, because the VAT was 20% of 250, not of 300.

The UK also has a reduced VAT rate of 5% and zero-rated goods. The United States has no VAT; sales tax is set by states and local governments and added at the till, so the rate depends on where you buy. With a combined rate of 7%, an item priced at 40 costs 42.80 at the register.

Finding the price before a discount or a rise

If a coat costs 63 after 30% off, the original price was 63 ÷ (1 − 0.30) = 90. Adding 30% to 63 gives 81.90, which is wrong, because the 30% was a share of the original price, not of the sale price. Rises work the same way: a salary that went up 8% to 54,000 was 54,000 ÷ 1.08 = 50,000 before.

Margin and markup

A shop that buys an item for 80 and sells it for 100 makes 20. Measured against the cost, that is a 25% markup. Measured against the selling price, it is a 20% margin. Both are correct, but they are not interchangeable.

The costly mistake comes when setting prices. For a 30% margin on an item that costs 70, the price must be 70 ÷ (1 − 0.30) = 100. Multiplying by 1.3 gives 91, and the margin is then only 23.08%.

Working it out in the percentage calculator

  1. Open the Percentage Calculator and choose a calculation.
  2. For stacked discounts, choose Discount and enter the original price with Discount 1 and Discount 2. Press Add a discount for a third one.
  3. For a rise, a fall or a markup, choose Change and enter the old and new values. When the two values are rates, such as 6 and 7.5, the Difference is the change in percentage points.
  4. For tax, choose VAT / tax, then say whether the price excludes or includes tax. The buttons fill in the UK rates of 20% and 5%; type any other rate, such as your local sales tax.
  5. For a margin, choose X is what % of Y and enter the profit as the number and the selling price as the total.

There is no separate mode for finding the price before a discount; use the division shown above.

Questions

How do I work out 50% off plus an extra 20% off?
Multiply what is left: 0.5 × 0.8 = 0.4, so you pay 40% of the original price and the total discount is 60%, not 70%. An item marked 300 drops to 150, then to 120.
What is the difference between a 2% rise and a 2-point rise?
A 2-point rise adds 2 to the percentage, for example from 5% to 7%. A 2% rise multiplies it by 1.02, for example from 5% to 5.1%. Changes in interest rates and inflation are usually reported in points.
How do I find the price before VAT on a receipt?
Divide the total by 1 plus the VAT rate. At 20% VAT, a total of 60 is 60 ÷ 1.2 = 50 before VAT, and the VAT is 10. At the 5% reduced rate, divide by 1.05.
Why does a 10% rise followed by a 10% fall not get back to the start?
The fall is taken from the higher price. 100 rises 10% to 110, and 10% off 110 is 11, which leaves 99.