Flat rate vs reducing-balance interest: why the same 6% can cost almost twice as much

Car dealers and personal-loan shops often quote a flat rate, while mortgages are priced on the reducing balance. On the same loan, 6% flat over three years charges nearly twice the interest of 6% on the reducing balance. Here is the arithmetic.

Updated

The difference is what the rate is charged on

  • Flat rate (called an add-on rate in the US): interest each month = original loan × rate ÷ 12. It stays the same from the first payment to the last, even though you owe less every month.
  • Reducing balance (also called an effective or declining-balance rate): interest each month = balance still owed × rate ÷ 12. As you repay principal, the interest shrinks.

A reducing-balance loan can be repaid in two ways. A fixed payment (annuity) keeps every payment equal; early payments are mostly interest. A fixed principal schedule repays the same slice of principal each month plus interest on the balance, so the payments fall over time. Most mortgages use the fixed payment.

Example: a loan of 20,000 over 36 months

Method, 6%PaymentTotal interest
Flat rate655.563,600.00
Fixed payment608.441,903.79
Fixed principal655.561,850.00

All three charge 6% a year; the last two are reducing-balance loans. The flat-rate and fixed payments stay the same every month. The fixed-principal payment is 655.56 only in the first month and falls each month to 558.33 in month 36.

At the same headline rate, the flat loan charges 1,696.21 more interest than the fixed-payment loan. Its interest is 100 every month, including month 36, when only 555.56 is still owed. In the same month the fixed-payment loan charges 3.03 of interest.

YearFlat interestReducing interest
11,200.001,029.39
21,200.00642.55
31,200.00231.86

Reducing-balance interest falls because the balance falls: 13,728.12 is owed at the end of the first year and 7,069.41 at the end of the second.

If you pay the loan off early

On the flat-rate loan the principal part of each payment is a fixed 555.56, so the balance actually falls faster at first than on the fixed-payment loan. After 12 payments the flat loan's remaining principal is 13,333.33 and the fixed-payment loan's is 13,728.12. If you settle at that point and the lender charges only the remaining principal with no penalty, you have paid 1,200.00 of interest on the flat loan and 1,029.39 on the other. The gap is 170.61, far less than the 1,696.21 it reaches by month 36. The extra cost of a flat rate piles up in the later years, when you owe little but still pay interest on the full 20,000.

Converting a flat rate to a reducing-balance rate

The equivalent rate is the reducing-balance rate whose fixed payment equals the flat-rate payment. For 6% flat over 36 months, a payment of 655.56 needs a reducing-balance rate of about 11.08% a year. The answer depends on the term, so no single multiplier works:

FlatReducing, 36 months
3%5.68%
4%7.51%
5%9.31%
6%11.08%
8%14.55%
10%17.92%

For 6% flat, the equivalent is 10.90% over 12 months, 11.13% over 24, 10.97% over 48 and 10.85% over 60. The shortcut 2n ÷ (n + 1) × flat rate, where n is the number of payments, is often quoted but runs high: it gives 11.68% for 36 months instead of 11.08%.

To work it out for your own offer in the loan and mortgage calculator:

  1. Enter the amount you are borrowing in Home or car price, or loan amount, a down payment of 0, the quoted rate and the term.
  2. Choose Flat rate and note the monthly payment.
  3. Choose Fixed payment (annuity) and raise the rate in small steps until the payment matches. For the example, 11.08% gives 655.53 and 11.09% gives 655.63.
  4. Switch the schedule to By month to compare the Interest and Balance columns, or press Download CSV to open it in a spreadsheet.

Flat rates and the APR

In the United States the Truth in Lending Act requires lenders to state an annual percentage rate (APR), and UK consumer-credit rules require a representative APR in adverts that quote a cost of credit. The APR is worked out on the balance actually owed and includes certain fees, so on a flat-rate loan it sits well above the flat rate. If an offer shows only a flat or add-on rate, ask for the APR in writing.

What to ask before you sign

  • Which method is used, and what the rate is on the reducing balance. Compare offers only once every rate is stated that way.
  • A written repayment schedule that splits each payment into principal and interest and shows the balance.
  • Fees on top of interest: arrangement fees, insurance, and whether they are paid upfront or added to the amount borrowed. The calculator leaves them out.
  • How an early payoff is calculated and whether there is a penalty. On a flat-rate loan, ask whether you pay only the remaining principal or some of the remaining flat interest as well.

Questions

Is a flat rate always more expensive than a reducing-balance rate?
At the same percentage and a term longer than one month, yes, because the flat rate keeps charging interest on money you have already repaid. A flat-rate offer can still be cheaper if its percentage is much lower: 5% flat over 36 months matches about 9.31% on the reducing balance, which beats a 10% reducing-balance loan.
Which is cheaper, fixed payment or fixed principal?
Fixed principal, because it repays the loan faster at the start. On 20,000 at 6% over 36 months it costs 1,850.00 in interest against 1,903.79 for fixed payments. The trade-off is a higher first payment: 655.56 against 608.44.
What reducing-balance rate matches 6% flat over five years?
About 10.85% a year. Over three years it is about 11.08%. The equivalent changes with the term, so check it for your own loan.
Should I compare offers by the monthly payment?
Only when the term and the amount borrowed are the same. A longer term lowers the payment and raises the total interest. Compare the total of all payments and the APR, together with the payment you can afford.